Gainesville Real Estate Search
Realtor®  ·  Rabell Realty Group  ·  North Central Florida

Nancy "Trey" Anderson

Local knowledge. A lifetime of hands-on experience.

Horse Properties  ·  Historic Homes  ·  Acreage & Rural Living
Rabell Realty Group
Former Thoroughbred Trainer & Breeder
Micanopy · McIntosh · Archer
Horse Farms & Acreage
Historic & Vintage Homes
LGBTQ+ Friendly
About Trey

Unique properties deserve a Realtor who understands them.

Nancy "Trey" Anderson took a less conventional road to real estate — and that may be exactly why she is so comfortable with properties that don't fit the conventional mold.

Before becoming a Realtor, Trey built a career and a life around horses, working as a professional horse trainer and breaking and training young horses in Ocala. Along the way, she has also been an innkeeper, farmer, personal assistant and old-home renovator. Her New England roots helped cultivate an appreciation for antiques, craftsmanship and older homes, while her years around horses and farms gave her the practical experience to understand land and equestrian properties in a way that can't be learned from a property description.

Today, those experiences come together in her real estate career. Trey specializes in Micanopy, McIntosh and the rural communities spanning southern Alachua County and northern Marion County, with particular experience in horse farms, acreage, historic and vintage homes, and properties that are simply hard to categorize. She enjoys the details and stories that make these homes different — and understands that successfully buying or selling them often requires more research, preparation and problem-solving than a conventional residential transaction.

For sellers, Trey is particularly attentive to what needs to happen before a property reaches the market. She works closely with her clients to identify priorities, prepare the home and property, position its distinctive features and navigate the issues that can arise during inspections and negotiations. Her approach is hands-on, thoughtful and highly personal.

For buyers, she enjoys getting beyond the basic wish list to understand how someone actually wants to live. Sometimes that means a historic home with original character. Sometimes it's acreage, a farmhouse or enough pasture and fencing for horses. And sometimes it's a property a buyer wasn't quite sure how to describe until they found it.

That appreciation for country living isn't just part of Trey's business. She lives it herself on wooded acreage in Archer, Florida, where the surrounding forest gives her beloved hound dogs plenty of room to run, explore and enjoy the land. Her own lifestyle gives her a personal understanding of why buyers seek out privacy, acreage and a little more room between neighbors — and why the right rural property is about much more than the house.

Trey also proudly provides inclusive, LGBTQ+ friendly real estate representation and welcomes clients from all backgrounds. She believes people should be able to work with a Realtor they trust, communicate openly with and know will advocate for them throughout the transaction.

Horses may no longer be Trey's full-time profession, but they are never very far from her life. Between her lifelong connection to horses, her hounds, her love of older homes and her own life in rural North Central Florida, Trey has found a real estate niche that feels very much like home.

Nancy "Trey" Anderson, REALTOR® with Rabell Realty Group
Nancy "Trey" Anderson · Rabell Realty Group
What Trey Focuses On

Where a lifetime of hands-on experience pays off.

01 — Horse Farms & Equine Properties

Horse properties aren't just homes with acreage.

Trey's years as a professional horse trainer give her firsthand knowledge of what makes an equestrian property truly functional. From pasture configuration and fencing to barns, access, outbuildings and the practical realities of caring for horses, she brings an experienced eye to properties that can be difficult to evaluate from a standard listing. Whether buying or selling a small horse property, working farm or larger acreage, Trey understands that the land and improvements can matter every bit as much as the house.

02

Micanopy & McIntosh

Local expertise in two of North Central Florida's most distinctive small towns.

Trey specializes in Micanopy and McIntosh and the rural areas surrounding them, working across the Alachua–Marion County line. These communities offer a mix of historic homes, farms, acreage, vintage properties and unconventional real estate that often requires more research and local knowledge than a typical subdivision sale. She understands why buyers are drawn to these towns — and what sellers need to consider when marketing properties that don't fit neatly into a standard category.

Explore Micanopy ›
03

Historic, Vintage & One-of-a-Kind Homes

For properties with a past — and buyers who appreciate them.

Trey's New England roots, interest in antiques and personal experience renovating older homes have given her a particular appreciation for properties with history and character. She regularly works with homes that are older, unusual or simply difficult to compare to the house next door — and understands that selling a vintage or historic home means identifying what makes it special without overlooking the practical issues buyers may encounter.

04

Rural & Acreage Properties

Real estate gets more complicated once the property extends beyond the house.

Rural transactions can involve acreage, wells, septic systems, fencing, agricultural improvements, outbuildings, access, land use and other considerations that aren't typically part of a conventional neighborhood sale. Trey is comfortable with the unconventional. Her background as a farmer, horse trainer and old-home renovator gives her a practical perspective when helping buyers and sellers navigate rural properties throughout southern Alachua and northern Marion County.

05

Inclusive & LGBTQ+ Friendly Real Estate

Everyone deserves to feel comfortable being themselves during a real estate transaction.

Trey proudly provides welcoming, judgment-free representation to buyers and sellers from all backgrounds, including members of the LGBTQ+ community. Choosing a Realtor is about more than experience with contracts and property — it's about finding someone you trust, can speak openly with and know will advocate for you. For clients looking for an LGBTQ+ friendly Realtor in Gainesville, Micanopy or the surrounding communities, Trey offers both an inclusive approach and years of real estate experience.

A young Trey Anderson with a Thoroughbred, 1989
From The Barn To The Closing Table

Before the listings, there were horses.

Trey spent years as a professional horse trainer and breeder — breaking and legging up young Thoroughbreds, running a breeding and racing facility, and learning every corner of a working farm. That world taught her how to read a property the way most agents never can.

Working with horse owners also taught her how to deliver good news and bad news alike: diplomacy and tact are a must, but honesty and candor are her best assets.

"With one glance at a barn, I can assess its function and condition. I'm a horse-farm property detective."
Trey Anderson with a rescued hound puppy in downtown Micanopy
A Life She Actually Lives

Wooded acreage, good hounds, and room to breathe.

Trey lives the rural life she helps her clients find — on wooded acreage in Archer, where her hound dogs have all the room they need to run and explore. It's why she understands, firsthand, that the right country property is about far more than the house: it's privacy, land, and a little more room between neighbors.

That same care extends to every client. Community is family, and that's how Trey treats the people she works with.

Good To Know

Questions about horses, history & rural land.

Horse & Equestrian Properties
What should buyers look for when purchasing a horse property in Micanopy, McIntosh or the surrounding area?

The buyer's specific needs dictate the search. How many horses you have determines the required acreage, and whether you have show horses, racehorses or pleasure horses determines the barn facilities you'll want — typically amenities like a wash rack, tack room and hay storage. Buyers almost always prioritize the horses' needs over the house itself.

Pleasure horses spend more time outside and may only need run-in sheds, but they require larger pastures. Professional sport horses need safe, secure paddocks with board fencing; those paddocks are usually smaller because the horses are turned out individually for limited times. Racehorse owners may need a property with a track for breaking and training, while dressage and barrel-racing horses require rings with proper footing.

What makes a property truly suitable for horses rather than simply a house with acreage?

As a former Thoroughbred trainer and breeder, I know suitability comes down to functional layout. I needed enough pasture to offer proper turnout for mares and foals, but also distinct, smaller paddocks for horses in training, along with a track or field suitable for legging up young horses. It's the arrangement and function of the land — not just the acreage — that makes a property work.

What should a seller do to prepare a horse farm or acreage property before putting it on the market?

Ideally, the fields are mowed, the fences are intact and the barn is well maintained. I recently saw a barn that had to be burned as a result of termites invading — and it almost cost the sale. The condition of the working parts of the property matters just as much as the house.

How did your career as a professional horse trainer influence the way you work as a Realtor today?

Working with horse owners taught me how to deliver good and bad news to clients — diplomacy and tact are a must, but honesty and candor are my best assets.

Running a breeding and racing facility taught me all the nuances of multi-building properties. There is never just one thing to worry about, but for me it was always putting the horses first. With one glance at a barn, I can immediately assess its functionality and condition: Is there enough electricity? A bathroom in the barn? Where's the septic on that? I'm a horse-farm property detective.

Historic & Vintage Homes
What should someone know before buying an older or historic home in Micanopy or McIntosh?

Older and historic homes can have problems with old, uninsurable or deteriorating pipes, shifting soil, or rotting wood that can cause piers to sink or lean out of plumb. Damp conditions can compromise beams and joists, so a knowledgeable professional should inspect all of the home with particular attention to the foundation.

That said, older homes have incredible character. Coming from New England originally, I've lived in homes built as far back as 1789. In the McIntosh and Micanopy areas, homes can be up to 150 years old. Their beauty comes from old heart-pine floors, wavy glass in tall windows, and original heart-pine or bald-cypress clapboard siding that still holds up. The outdoor charm comes from the wraparound porches and established landscaping.

How do you determine the value of a unique home when there aren't many comparable sales nearby?

You may have to look outside the area, in other small towns, for comparable homes with similar size, age and unique qualities. It isn't an easy feat, so you want to use a Realtor with knowledge and experience of unique or rural homes. I can help you with that.

What should sellers of older homes do before listing their property?

I always suggest having the septic emptied and any repairs to it or the drainfield corrected, with a dated invoice from your contractor to share with buyers. It's also important to conduct a preemptive home inspection to avoid surprises — especially a four-point inspection, which will help determine whether the roof, HVAC, plumbing and electrical will cause any issues for the new buyer's insurance.

It's best to correct those before listing, or have a plan to correct them before closing with an appropriate offer. With many rural homes, I'll also help you make sure there are no open permits for work that may have been done, so you're aware of possible issues ahead of time.

What are some of the biggest surprises buyers encounter when purchasing a farm, acreage or rural home?

There are many, but the most common are roofs with no permits, foundation beams splitting, termites, and a lack of proper insulation — or none at all. These are exactly the kinds of things I watch for early.

Living in Micanopy & McIntosh
Why do buyers choose Micanopy, Florida?

The rural lifestyle is a major reason, as is its location equidistant from Ocala and Gainesville. That easy access to Gainesville from the south beats snarled traffic when traveling east to west in town. The downtown area has some of the best antique stores and cafés, and they host a wonderful festival every year.

Two of the absolute best food spots are right off 441 in Micanopy: Pearl Country Store & Barbeque is located at a gas station but cooks the best BBQ in North Central Florida, and the original Blue Highway Pizza is always a great lunch spot for their pizza and the local-favorite Micanopy Tossed Salad. Everyone is so friendly — and you have access to one of the best bass-fishing lakes in the country, Orange Lake.

What is it like living in McIntosh, Florida?

McIntosh offers a community-oriented lifestyle, with a park, tennis courts and a community center right in town at Van Ness Park. It's a quaint, old Victorian-style town that values its trees and history, and it hosts a magnificent annual 1890s Festival. Orange Lake provides some of the best black crappie, bluegill, redear sunfish and largemouth bass fishing in the country.

Buying, Selling & Working With Trey
Is buying a rural property different from buying a home in a Gainesville or Ocala subdivision? How?

The major differences are well and septic. In town you have city water, but in more rural areas you'll be on a well — so when you lose power during a storm, you won't have the convenience of city water. But it's a lifestyle of living on more land, with space to stretch out, explore and have more animals or farming ability. You get privacy, no HOA and a multitude of other advantages that often outweigh any disadvantages of convenience compared with living inside a city.

Why is providing LGBTQ+ friendly real estate representation important to you?

My community is LGBTQ, and they're important to me as I am to them. There's nothing more rewarding than finding that perfect home for folks who just want to house-hunt — not explain who they are and what they may need. Community is family, and that's how we treat each other.

Let's Talk

Ready to find something a little different?

Whether it's a horse farm, a historic home, acreage or a rural property that's hard to categorize — let's talk about what you're looking for.

Get in Touch
Nancy "Trey" Anderson, Realtor® · Rabell Realty Group · Micanopy · McIntosh · Archer · North Central Florida

Explore Micanopy's Newest Listings

17931 Se County Road 234, Micanopy
$970,700
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Glenellen SubDv. ⋅ 32667 Zip Code
HOBBY FARM for working animal lovers. 30 minutes(22miles) to WEC in Ocala. Improved paddocks, small center aisle barn.Beautiful natural wooded land behind house with bridge over small creek, pines surrounding small pond. You are own personal walking trails. Welcome to a beautiful horse farm which is offering the perfect combination of comfortable country living, functional farm facilities, and plenty of room for horses, goats, and other livestock. The property provides a peaceful rural setting while offering everything needed for an active equestrian and agricultural lifestyle. The attractive main home offers a comfortable and inviting place to live, with ample space for family and guests and wonderful views of the surrounding acreage and filled with natural light. The spacious living area features special, distinctive wood River recovered heart pine flooring that adds character, warmth, and a beautiful country feel to the house. An open and clear floor plan creates a bright, welcoming atmosphere, with plenty of windows and sunshine throughout the living spaces to brighten your days and showcase the peaceful surroundings. Also, it has a bonus room for your office, and convenient 2-car-attached garage provides everyday parking and storage. Also, outside you can enjoy plenty of space for grilling on your weekends or doing gardening. You will love this farm. For the farm enthusiast, the property features a substantial additional outbuilding with a 3-car garage, providing excellent space for tractors, trailers, ATVs, lawn equipment, tools, and other farm machinery. The building adds tremendous versatility for equipment storage, a workshop, or future hobby and agricultural uses. The property also includes stabling and livestock facilities designed to accommodate horses, goats, and other animals. There is ample acreage for turnout areas, pastures, paddocks, and riding or recreational activities, special areas planted with Bahia grass pasture. The open land provides plenty of flexibility for creating the ideal setup for your animals and farming needs.Enjoy your 9.5-Acre Horse Farm & Country Estate.

17931 Se County Road 234, Micanopy

17819 Sr-25, Micanopy
$315,000
N/A SubDv. ⋅ 32667 Zip Code
Discover the potential of this rare 16-acre property located at Micanopy with direct frontage and easy access right off US Highway 441. Tucked behind a gated entrance and surrounded by mature trees, this private and peaceful property offers the perfect blend of seclusion, convenience, and opportunity in one of North Central Florida’s most desirable rural settings. Whether you are searching for a private homestead, investment opportunity, mini farm, recreational retreat, or future homesite with acreage, this versatile property delivers endless possibilities. Enjoy wide open space, natural surroundings, and the tranquility of country living while still being just minutes from I-75 for an easy commute to both Gainesville and Ocala. The property currently features a two-bedroom, one-bath single-family home with an existing well already on site. The home is in need of a full rehab, creating an excellent opportunity for investors, builders, or buyers looking to renovate or start fresh and build their dream property. With 16 private acres, there is ample room for horses, livestock, equipment storage, gardening, recreational vehicles, additional structures, or expansion opportunities. Buyers searching for acreage in Florida will appreciate the combination of privacy, gated access, mature trees, functional land, and convenient highway access. This property is ideal for those seeking rural living with close proximity to shopping, dining, hospitals, universities, and all the amenities of Gainesville and Ocala. If you have been looking for private acreage with flexibility, natural beauty, and incredible potential, this unique Micanopy property is a must-see opportunity.

17819 Sr-25, Micanopy

17704 Se 59th Street, Micanopy
$1,498,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Tuscawilla Lake Estates SubDv. ⋅ 32667 Zip Code
This is not just a home. It’s a sanctuary tucked beneath a canopy of grand oaks and Old Florida beauty — where luxury living meets complete privacy and breathtaking natural scenery. Privately gated and fully renovated from top to bottom, this extraordinary estate in historic Micanopy offers nearly 5,000 heated square feet of refined living space on 8.2 beautiful acres overlooking an unobstructed 400-acre protected preserve. From more than 140 feet above the preserve land’s water level, the elevated views here are something you simply cannot replicate — endless sunsets, towering moss-draped oaks, wildlife, and complete serenity with no rear neighbors in sight. From the moment you arrive, the property makes a statement. Elevated architecture, dramatic walls of glass, designer finishes, and resort-style ambiance blend together to create a home that feels worlds away while still remaining remarkably convenient to both Gainesville and Ocala. Located just a short scenic drive through the Paynes Prairie State Park to the University of Florida, world-renowned UF Health/Shands Hospital, metropolitan Gainesville, Ocala, and the World Equestrian Center, this location offers the perfect balance of luxury, privacy, and accessibility. Inside, the home has been thoughtfully reimagined with expansive living spaces designed for both entertaining and everyday comfort. Soaring ceilings and oversized windows flood the interiors with natural light while perfectly framing the preserve beyond. Every room was designed to bring the outdoors in, creating a seamless connection to the surrounding landscape. The extensive renovation includes three new HVAC systems, updated mechanicals, all new flooring, beautifully renovated bathrooms, new and complete stucco exterior finishes, and two expansive decks perfectly positioned to take in the preserve views. The layout was also designed with functionality in mind, featuring both the primary suite and a private guest suite on the main level, creating an ideal setup for multigenerational living or luxury guest accommodations. A brand-new dedicated workout room adds yet another layer of lifestyle-focused living to this already exceptional property. Outside is where this property truly becomes unforgettable. Whether enjoying coffee at sunrise while looking down at the deer roaming in the yard, hosting elegant outdoor gatherings under the surrounding, lighted, majestic grand oak trees, or simply listening to the quiet sounds of nature from your back terrace, this estate delivers a level of peace and privacy that is becoming increasingly rare in today’s luxury market. Properties like this don’t come along often — fully renovated, gated, acreage, preserve views, and positioned perfectly between Gainesville and Ocala in one of Central Florida’s most naturally beautiful settings. Extraordinary isn’t a feature. It’s the standard.

17704 Se 59th Street, Micanopy

11816 Se County Road 234, Micanopy
$2,400,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ N/A SubDv. ⋅ 32667 Zip Code
One of a Kind Paynes Prairie Ranch Property is being made available for the first time in 63 years! [With 90 Acres MOL] The Hunting on this property boast some of the Best in the State of Florida! Paynes Prairie State Preserve, with its thousands of acres of protected land & wildlife, borders this property on 2 sides. The wildlife existing here have the opportunity to grow large due to the lack of hunting pressure and increased nutrient levels found in this enriched ecological environment. Abundant game frequents the property: deer, turkey, game birds, bobcat, bear, wild hog, coyotes, & the occasional Florida panther. Please see provided pictures from trail cameras. Numerous trophy Bucks & Gobblers have been harvested over the years. The Trophy Racks on these deer resemble that of deer harvested in the northern States. The property consists of improved pastureland for grazing & cutting hay, timber & hardwood forest, along with some areas that hold water, including Stafford Pond. Owner has used the property for raising livestock. Property is fenced and cross fenced. Many maintained trails run throughout the property providing an opportunity to get away from it all and unwind with nature. Several blinds are set up on the property. There is approximately 1270 feet of paved road frontage, providing easy access. The main homestead was designed & built by architect Frank Frederics. The home is 3341 square foot living space consisting of 4 bedrooms, and 3.5 bathrooms, which includes a detached guest house. He used interior wood designs in the home which were milled from trees on the property. The home is block construction with excellent use of wood for the interior. The homestead compound is completely fenced with multiple out buildings, including a detached office w/AC, enclosed workshop, covered open work garage, carport, & large equipment covered port. There is a horse stall with turn out Paddock. Dog Kennel. Vegetable garden area, fruit trees & room for more projects. Property is located just minutes from Micanopy, 15 minutes to Gainesville (University of Florida, Santa Fe college, UF Shands hospital, VA Hospital, major shopping, restaurants, airport, & hotels). The local area provides excellent freshwater fishing with an abundant of lakes & rivers to frequent. One can be in the Gulf of Mexico saltwater fishing in little over an hour. For the record properties like this one are disappearing every day in Florida. Come see what natural “Old Florida” should look like! This is truly a must see!

11816 Se County Road 234, Micanopy

11804 Se County Road 234, Micanopy
$1,200,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ N/A SubDv. ⋅ 32667 Zip Code
One of a Kind Country Retreat! Custom Jacobsen Home on 51.7 acres located on CR 234 just outside Micanopy. Property is surrounded by large parcels of Paynes Prairie, timber & hardwood forest, & farm land. Abundant game frequent the property: deer, turkey, game birds, bobcat, bear, & the occasional Florida panther. The property consists of improved pasture land for grazing & cutting hay, timber & hardwood forest, along with some areas that hold water. Owner has used the property for raising livestock, with a set of cattle pens present. Property is fenced and cross fenced. The best use is recreational use through enjoying a nature retreat, wildlife observation, & hunting. The amount of abundant game that is drawn to this property from surrounding lands is incredible. Please see provided pictures from trail cameras. Numerous trophy Bucks & gobblers have been harvested over the years. Many maintained trails run throughout the property providing an opportunity to get away from it all and unwind with nature. Several blinds are set up on the property. There are two target ranges located on the property. There is approximately 815 feet of paved road frontage, providing easy access. Located just minutes from Micanopy, 25 minutes to Gainesville (University of Florida, Santa Fe college, UF Shands hospital, VA Hospital, major shopping, restaurants, airport, & hotels). The local area provides excellent fresh water fishing with an abundant of lakes & rivers to frequent. One can be in the Gulf of Mexico saltwater fishing in little over an hour. For the record properties like this one are disappearing everyday in Florida. Come see what natural “Old Florida” should look like! This is truly a must see!

11804 Se County Road 234, Micanopy

Start Your Search